About May Wolf Insurance
Your Neighbors in Protection
Founded right here in Fishers, Indiana, May Wolf Insurance was built on the belief that insurance should be personal. We know that behind every policy is a family, a home, or a business that represents years of hard work.
We aren’t a corporate call center; we are your neighbors who see you at the Fishers Farmers Market or cheering on the Tigers at a Friday night game. Our deep roots in Hamilton County allow us to understand the specific risks and local regulations that matter to you. As an independent agency, we don’t work for one big insurance company—we work for you. * Integrity First: We provide honest advice, even if it means telling you that you’re already in a good spot.
Local Advocacy: When you have a claim, you call us, not an 800-number. We stand by you until the job is done.
Expert Options: We compare rates from over 20 top-rated carriers to ensure you get the best value in Indiana.
Our Trusted Partners
We partner with the industry’s leading insurance carriers to provide you with a wide range of coverage options at competitive prices.
| Carrier | Specialized In | Why We Choose Them |
| Progressive | Auto & Bundling | Leading technology and competitive “Name Your Price” tools. |
| Liberty Mutual | Home & Life | Exceptional claims service and comprehensive family protection. |
| Travelers | Business & General Liability | One of the oldest, most stable commercial insurers in the country. |
| Safeco | Personal Lines | Highly customizable policies tailored to your specific lifestyle. |
| Chubb | High-Value Assets | Premier protection for luxury homes and high-end collections. |
| Selective | Flood & Specialty | Expertise in niche markets and unique property risks. |
Let’s Find the Right Fit
Ready to see how these carriers can work for you? We’ll do the shopping so you don’t have to.